Mingo Logo Formerly SensrTrx

Mingo Smart Factory vs. Tulip: In-Depth Comparison 

A Brief Overview of Smart Factory Software

Smart factories are the future of manufacturing, where traditional production processes are replaced with advanced digital technologies. 

They use connected systems, automation, and real-time data to optimize production, improve efficiency, and drive growth. With smart factories, manufacturers can reduce waste, minimize downtime, and increase output. 

It’s a new era of production where machine learning, artificial intelligence, and the Internet of Things are transforming the way things are made. Embrace the future and upgrade to a smart factory today!

Importance of Digital Transformation in Manufacturing

Digital transformation is revolutionizing the manufacturing industry, providing new opportunities for growth and competitiveness. By adopting digital technologies, manufacturers can improve efficiency, reduce costs, and enhance the customer experience. 

With real-time data and analytics, manufacturers can make informed decisions, optimize production, and minimize downtime. Digital transformation also enables manufacturers to develop new products, enter new markets, and stay ahead of the competition.

Introducing Mingo Smart Factory and Tulip

Mingo Smart Factory

Mingo Smart Factory and Tulip are two digital solutions designed to help manufacturers drive growth and improve efficiency. Both solutions offer real-time visibility, analytics, and data collection tools to help manufacturers streamline their operations.

Mingo Smart Factory provides a complete digital toolset that includes real-time visibility, operational awareness, and intuitive analytics. It also features alerts, scoreboards, operator screens, automated data collection, customizable dashboards, automated reporting, labor tracking, pivot tables, and integrations. 

With Mingo Smart Factory, manufacturers can escape manual spreadsheets and automate data collection to quickly get a clear view of their data for better and faster insights.

Tulip, on the other hand, is an app-based solution designed to manage and visualize global operations in real-time. It offers composable, edge-native solutions that improve efficiency and scale the workforce. 

Tulip

Tulip is suitable for large-scale manufacturing, life sciences, and medical device assembly. It features connected apps that power operations and a material systems replenishment app that helps define “Kanban loops.”

Both Mingo Smart Factory and Tulip offer unique solutions to help manufacturers drive growth and improve efficiency. The choice between them will depend on the specific needs and goals of each manufacturer.

Mingo Smart Factory

Company Background and Mission

Mingo Smart Factory is a manufacturing productivity and analytics software that provides real-time visibility on the factory floor. Their mission is to reduce complexities and improve flow in the manufacturing industry. 

Mingo Smart Factory empowers manufacturers to start small and easily grow from one machine to thousands of machines globally. The company is made up of tech-forward individuals who believe in continuous learning and are dedicated to solving manufacturing problems through technology.

Mingo Smart Factory is the complete and smart analytics and productivity platform for growing manufacturing businesses, providing easy and effective solutions that help reduce downtime, improve on-time delivery, and increase profitability.

Key Features and Offerings

Mingo Smart Factory provides real-time visibility into the factory floor through its cloud-based platform. It integrates seamlessly into existing configurations and workflows, collecting data from both equipment and people. 

This data is translated into actionable insights, allowing manufacturers to make better decisions. 

Mingo Smart Factory offers a range of features, including real-time visibility alerts, a scoreboard, operator screens, automated data collection, operational awareness dashboards, automated reporting, scheduling and management, labor tracking, intuitive analytics, pivot tables, integrations with ERP and other software, and the ability to collect and correlate process data. 

These features are designed to help manufacturers reduce downtime, improve on-time delivery, and increase profitability.

Core Capabilities

Internet of Things (IoT) Integration

Mingo Smart Factory’s IoT Edge Platform revolutionizes the way data is collected and analyzed in the manufacturing industry. It provides a secure and central device that bridges the communication gap between machines and the cloud. 

With the IoT Edge Platform, you get real-time visibility into your factory floor and are able to detect anomalies, receive configurable alerts, and automatically update your devices. 

With the ability to integrate with 100s of different PLCs, controllers, and databases, Mingo Smart Factory’s IoT Edge Platform ensures that you never lose sight of your operations, even in the event of an internet connection failure.

Data Analytics and Visualization

Mingo Smart Factory provides a cutting-edge solution for manufacturers with its manufacturing analytics platform. The platform simplifies data collection and analysis, replacing manual reporting and reducing errors. 

The platform provides insights into key production metrics such as scrap, downtime, and performance to drive improvements and increase profitability. The data-driven decisions facilitated by Mingo Smart Factory are made possible by its ability to put all data in context. 

The platform also features a mobile app with real-time machine and operator data and alerts for machine cell OEE, downtime, and scrap. Using Mingo Smart Factory can drive continuous improvement efforts by identifying and prioritizing kaizen events and measuring progress.

Process Automation

Process automation plays a crucial role in the operations of a smart factory, and Mingo Smart Factory is no exception. The platform offers comprehensive process automation solutions to streamline and optimize manufacturing operations. 

From data collection to real-time insights and decision-making, Mingo Smart Factory provides a seamless, automated process for manufacturers to improve efficiency, reduce downtime, and increase profitability. 

The platform integrates with a wide range of equipment and systems to ensure smooth operation, while its IoT Edge Platform provides secure, real-time communication between the factory floor and the cloud. With Mingo Smart Factory, manufacturers can rest assured that their processes are automated and optimized for maximum productivity and success.

Methodology and Ideology

Mingo Smart Factory follows a unique methodology and ideology that prioritizes practical solutions and results-driven outcomes. Their approach is designed to deliver the highest return on investment and the shortest time to value for the customers.

80% Out-of-The-Box Solutions

Mingo Smart Factory provides a wide range of out-of-the-box solutions that can be easily configured to meet the specific needs of your manufacturing operation. Their solutions work right out of the box, reducing the need for extensive customization and reducing the time required to get up and running.

Faster Implementation

Mingo Smart Factory’s approach is designed to get you up and running quickly, with minimal disruption to your existing operations. Their solutions are easy to implement and can be deployed in a matter of days or weeks, not months or years.

Higher ROI

Mingo Smart Factory delivers a higher return on investment by streamlining processes, reducing downtime, improving on-time delivery, and increasing profitability. It delivers measurable results quickly, so you can start seeing a positive impact on your bottom line right away.

Reduced Dependency on Consultants

Mingo Smart Factory is designed to be easy to use, with a user-friendly interface that requires minimal training. This reduces the need for extensive consulting services, which can be costly and time-consuming. Their approach empowers you to take control of your manufacturing operations with the flexibility and scalability to grow as your business grows.

Key Industries and Use Cases

Mingo Smart Factory offers a range of industry-specific software solutions to help manufacturers optimize their operations and improve productivity. 

Whether it’s in the automotive, consumer packaged goods, metal stamping and fabrication, plastic packaging, food and beverage, wood and millwork, or cannabis industries, Mingo Smart Factory has a solution that can help.

Automotive

Mingo Smart Factory’s automotive software provides real-time insights into plant operations, allowing manufacturers to reduce downtime, increase efficiency, and deliver on time to customers. It covers production planning, resource utilization, quality standards, capacity, and communication.

Consumer Packaged Goods

The consumer packaged goods software from Mingo Smart Factory helps manufacturers increase plant productivity by collecting and analyzing data from the floor. It covers production, downtime, and scrap metrics, allowing manufacturers to make data-driven decisions and deliver on time to customers.

Metal Stamping & Fabrication

Mingo Smart Factory’s metal fabrication software helps manufacturers address common production challenges, including scheduling, utilization, quality standards, capacity, and communication. The goal is to increase efficiency, solve problems, and provide real-time insights into plant operations.

Plastic Packaging

Mingo Smart Factory’s plastic manufacturing software provides purpose-built solutions for the industry, optimizing scheduling, production planning, and providing visual management resources. It helps reduce unplanned downtime and overtime, increase availability, and ensure on-time delivery.

Food & Beverage

Mingo Smart Factory’s food and beverage software provides insights into plant operations, allowing manufacturers to meet production targets and deliver on time without compromising quality. It covers trends, food safety, loss, throughput, maintenance, and cost reduction.

Cannabis

Mingo Smart Factory’s cannabis software helps cannabis manufacturers understand how the plant is operating and make data-driven decisions. It covers quality standards, yield goals, bottlenecks and loss, production per person per hour, and on-time delivery.

Customer Success Stories

Mingo’s Smart Factory solution has been instrumental in helping manufacturers achieve their goals and improve their processes. Here are just a few examples of how their customers have seen success:

  • Versatech: With automated, real-time data and visual dashboards, Versatech increased efficiency by finding problems, solving them quickly, and continuously improving processes.
  • Oral BioTech: By using Mingo Smart Factory, Oral BioTech was able to increase OEE by 25%, nearly eliminate scrap, and create a culture of visibility and transparency.
  • Tacony: By implementing Mingo Smart Factory, Tacony achieved 9x ROI and saved over $500k in unrealized revenue.
  • H&T Waterbury: With Mingo Smart Factory, H&T Waterbury reduced micro stoppages by 71% and drove continuous improvement projects based on data collected from the floor.
  • Lyons Blow Molding: By using Mingo Smart Factory, Lyons Blow Molding was able to reduce mistakes, increase the accuracy of data, and reduce non-value-added work.

Pricing and Deployment

Mingo Smart Factory offers flexible and customizable solutions to fit the unique needs and requirements of your organization. With pricing plans that range from Lean to Enterprise, there is a solution that is just right for you.

Lean: This plan is designed for manufacturers who are looking to ditch spreadsheets and whiteboards and instead spin up a digital source of truth for data collection and reporting. 

It includes real-time OEE, automatic cycle/part counts, automatic scrap counts, downtime detection, unlimited users, a gateway for connectivity, and line configuration.

Black Belt: This plan is for manufacturers who are looking to free up their time and resources with automated data collection that makes their factory more efficient. 

In addition to all the benefits of the Lean plan, it also includes auto scrap and downtime categorization, PLC connectivity, process data, scheduling, and API connectivity.

Enterprise: This plan is for manufacturers who are looking to expand beyond data and create a truly smart factory experience. 

In addition to all the benefits of the Black Belt plan, it also includes custom forms, custom calculations, custom fields, custom objects, and operator and labor tracking.

Pricing for Mingo Smart Factory consists of three components: licensing per machine or line per year, hardware needed to connect the software to your floor, and implementation fees. 

All of the pricing is fixed fee and transparent, making it easy to understand and budget for. If you have additional questions or want to learn more, their team is always here to help.

Tulip

Company Background and Mission

Tulip provides a simple yet powerful platform for frontline operations. Their platform helps companies transform their operations by empowering workers to solve problems and drive improvement.

With Tulip, you can easily connect your machines, people, and processes to gain real-time visibility into your operations. Their platform combines cutting-edge technologies like IoT, machine vision, augmented reality, and machine learning to help you optimize your operations and drive continuous improvement.

The platform is designed for the frontline, so it’s easy to use and requires no special training. Whether you’re in manufacturing, logistics, field service, or another industry, Tulip can help you transform your operations and drive results.

Key Features and Offerings

Tulip is transforming frontline operations with its industry-leading platform. The cloud-based, GxP-ready solution offers analytics and edge connectivity. The easy-to-use App Editor allows the creation of functional apps without code, and hardware integrations make it simple to connect devices and machines. 

Tulip provides real-time production insights through its manufacturing analytics and plugin expansion functionality. Tulip apps can be used on various devices and are customizable for each operation. 

The platform offers product insights, powerful reporting, real-time data, and multilingual support, empowering operators with apps in their native language.

Core Capabilities

End-to-end Integration

Tulip integrates with your existing systems and machines, connecting the systems that power your operations. The platform offers easy-to-use, out-of-the-box integrations or the ability to write your own. Tulip ensures secure data transfers with best-in-class security. 

With Tulip, you can push and pull data from your apps to connect your frontline to the backend, tracking work orders, inventory, BOMs, tools, scheduling, and more. Tulip also allows you to connect to external APIs and tools.

Real-Time Machine Monitoring

You can get a clear view of production by capturing real-time data from the machines used in your operations. Tulip offers real-time dashboards and built-in analytics to go beyond OEE. 

The platform also supports on-machine apps, guiding operators and collecting data with consistency. Tulip integrates human and machine workflows, making it easy to connect to machines with its intuitive, cost-effective hardware.

Scalability Across Sites and Teams

Tulip enables you to scale quickly and easily with its multisite capabilities. You can deploy to new sites with shared resources and ready-made Tulip Library apps and manage resources and apps across your organization. Tulip also provides multilingual support for your apps, making it easy to add translations for different languages.

Compliance Made Easy

Tulip simplifies compliance, reducing the burden of collecting and reviewing data for compliance. The platform provides features such as digital history records, review by exception, and audit trails.  

Tulip also offers automatic attributability, minimizing the risk of lost mission-critical data. Validation is made fast and easy with Tulip, as it comes validated with every long-term support version and detailed documentation.

Methodology and Ideology

Tulip’s approach to frontline operations is based on a toolkit methodology and a focus on customization and flexibility. The platform offers a wide range of features and capabilities to meet the unique needs of each operation while also providing the building blocks and starter kits necessary to get started quickly and efficiently.

Toolkit Approach

Tulip’s toolkit approach means that the platform is designed to be flexible and adaptable to the specific needs of each operation. With a range of features and capabilities, operations can select the tools they need to improve productivity, streamline processes, and achieve their goals. 

Whether you need to integrate with existing systems, collect real-time machine data, or expand functionality with plugins, Tulip has the tools you need to get the job done.

Customization and Flexibility

Tulip is designed with customization and flexibility in mind. The platform offers a range of options for customization, including the ability to create your own apps, connect to external APIs, and configure machine monitoring. 

With Tulip, operations can create solutions that are tailored to their specific needs while also taking advantage of the platform’s powerful features and capabilities.

Starter Kits and Building Blocks

Tulip’s library of ready-made apps and integration with external systems provides a solid foundation for operations to build. The platform also offers starter kits and building blocks, making it easier for operations to get up and running quickly and efficiently. 

Key Industries and Use Cases

In today’s fast-paced business environment, it’s important to have technology that can keep up. Tulip is a manufacturing platform that is designed to help companies across various industries optimize their operations and improve productivity, efficiency, and quality.

Food & Beverage 

Tulip helps companies in this industry by providing them with a platform that connects all of their operations, machines, and workers in one place. 

With Tulip, food and beverage manufacturers can digitize their work instructions, guide workers through complex tasks, measure line and machine performance, and sync data with their ERP systems. This helps companies increase their production capacity, reduce manual errors, and improve quality management.

Luxury Goods

Luxury goods are known for their premium materials, customized orders, and high-quality craftsmanship. Tulip helps companies in this industry by providing them with a platform that can automate tedious tasks, provide digital workflows for workers, and help track and trace materials and products. 

This helps companies reduce the burden of paperwork, improve quality management, and prevent costly defects and material escapes.

Biotech Manufacturing

Biotech manufacturing is a complex and regulated industry that requires a lot of attention to detail. Tulip helps companies in this industry by providing them with a platform that can simplify quality management, adhere to regulation standards, and improve traceability. 

With Tulip, biotech manufacturers can automate workflows, manage quality workflows from one place, and reduce validation efforts. This helps companies increase their success at audit time, minimize the risk of non-compliance, and improve quality management.

Medical Devices & Diagnostics

Tulip provides them with a platform that can simplify compliance, improve traceability, and ensure product quality. 

With Tulip, medical device and diagnostics manufacturers can digitize work instructions, connect to devices and systems, and simplify quality management. This helps companies reduce validation efforts, minimize the risk of non-compliance, and improve quality management.

Customer Success Stories

Tulip’s Frontline Operations Platform has been a game-changer for manufacturers looking to digitize their processes. Here are just a few examples of how their customers have seen success:

DMG Mori: DMG Mori digitized their spindle assembly line using Tulip, reducing the time required to perform quality checks and increasing visibility into the process. This led to improved efficiency and faster problem-solving. 

Pharma Manufacturer: A large multinational biopharmaceutical company used Tulip to digitize their standard operating procedures for a complex equipment line changeover procedure. 

By converting the process to Tulip apps, the company reduced the time required to perform the procedure from 14 days to just 3, minimized errors, and increased visibility into the process. 

Medical Device Manufacturer: A medical device manufacturer used Tulip to implement a next-gen MES at a fraction of the cost. 

By using Tulip’s platform to support all assembly operations with interactive apps, the company was able to guide and track the build process step-by-step and achieve real-time device manufacturing progress tracking. This led to improved efficiency and reduced waste.

Pricing and Deployment

Tulip Essentials is priced at $1200 per interface per year, with a minimum of 5 interfaces required. It is ideal for basic production visibility, quality, and assembly workflows and includes features such as Tulip Apps, Tulip Tables, Tulip Analytics, and access to Tulip’s Library, Community, and University.

Tulip Professional is priced at $2400 per interface per year, with a minimum of 10 interfaces required. It is designed for businesses that need to connect workflows to systems and devices and includes advanced edge connectivity, single sign-on, advanced user roles, and third-party integrations.

Tulip Enterprise is for businesses that need to scale solutions across their entire organization and is available through custom pricing. It includes workspaces, enterprise app exchange, multilingual apps, and app approval workflows.

For businesses in regulated industries, Tulip also offers a Regulated Industries tier with features such as eSignatures, auditable record history, and long-term support releases. This tier is available through custom pricing and requires a minimum of 10 interfaces.

In-Depth Comparison: Different Approaches

Mingo Smart Factory’s Out-of-The-Box Approach vs. Tulip’s Toolkit Approach

Implementation Speed

Mingo Smart Factory offers an out-of-the-box approach that allows manufacturers to quickly implement the solution. The software is designed to be easy to use and requires minimal setup, making it ideal for manufacturers who want to digitize their processes as quickly as possible.

Tulip’s toolkit approach, on the other hand, provides the building blocks and starter kits necessary for operations to get up and running quickly and efficiently. However, it requires a deeper understanding of the platform and may take longer to implement than Mingo Smart Factory’s out-of-the-box approach.

Customization and Flexibility

Mingo Smart Factory offers a user-friendly interface and a range of features and capabilities, making it easy for manufacturers to get started quickly. 

However, the platform may not be as flexible and customizable as Tulip’s toolkit approach, which provides a wide range of options for customization, including the ability to create your own apps, connect to external APIs, and configure machine monitoring.

Dependency on Consultants

Mingo Smart Factory’s out-of-the-box approach may require less dependency on consultants than Tulip’s toolkit approach. With Tulip, operations may need to rely on consultants to help them select the right tools and configure the platform to meet their specific needs.

Return on Investment

Both Mingo Smart Factory and Tulip offer a return on investment, but the specifics may vary depending on the manufacturer’s needs and the approach they choose. 

With Mingo Smart Factory’s out-of-the-box approach, manufacturers may see a quicker return on investment as the platform is designed to be easy to use and requires minimal setup. 

Tulip’s toolkit approach may require more investment upfront, but the long-term benefits, such as the ability to customize the platform to meet specific needs, may result in a higher return on investment.

Complexity vs. Simplicity

Mingo Smart Factory’s User-Friendly Interface

Mingo Smart Factory offers a user-friendly interface that makes it easy for manufacturers to get started quickly. The platform is designed to be easy to use and requires minimal setup, making it ideal for manufacturers who want to digitize their processes without the added complexity of a customizable platform.

Tulip’s Customizable Platform

Tulip’s platform is designed to be flexible and adaptable to the specific needs of each operation. With a range of features and capabilities, operations can select the tools they need to improve productivity, streamline processes, and achieve their goals. However, this level of customization may also add complexity to the implementation process.

Industry Focus and Use Cases

Mingo Smart Factory’s Target Industries

Mingo Smart Factory’s target industries are primarily focused on the manufacturing sector, including but not limited to automotive, consumer goods, electronics, and aerospace. The solution’s key features and offerings make it a perfect fit for these industries, which require real-time data collection, reporting, and continuous improvement of processes.

Tulip’s Target Industries

Tulip is designed to help companies across various industries optimize their operations and improve productivity, efficiency, and quality. The platform is ideal for companies in industries such as food and beverage, luxury goods, biotech manufacturing, and medical devices and diagnostics. 

Conclusion

Mingo Smart Factory vs. Tulip: In-Depth Comparison 

Mingo Smart Factory and Tulip are two leading smart factory solutions that offer manufacturers a range of features and capabilities to improve their operations and drive results. However, the two solutions differ in their approach to implementation, customization, and industry focus.

Mingo Smart Factory adopts an out-of-the-box approach, offering a user-friendly interface and real-time data collection for manufacturers looking for a fast and simple solution. On the other hand, Tulip offers a toolkit approach, providing a customizable platform that can be tailored to the specific needs of each operation.

When it comes to implementation speed, Mingo Smart Factory is known for its quick setup, allowing manufacturers to get started in a matter of days. 

Tulip, on the other hand, may require more time to implement as it is designed to be flexible and adaptable to the needs of each operation.

In terms of customization, Mingo Smart Factory offers a range of pricing plans to fit the unique needs and requirements of each organization. And Tulip provides a wide range of features and capabilities, making it easy to create solutions that are tailored to specific needs.

Mingo Smart Factory is ideal for manufacturers in various industries, including electronics, automotive, and more. Tulip is specifically designed for frontline operations and is ideal for companies in the food and beverage, luxury goods, biotech manufacturing, and medical devices and diagnostics industries.

When choosing a smart factory solution, it is important to consider your specific industry, operations, and goals. Both Mingo Smart Factory and Tulip offer strong solutions for manufacturers looking to improve their operations and drive results. 

It is recommended to carefully evaluate the features and capabilities of each solution and choose the one that best fits the needs of your business.

The choice between Mingo Smart Factory and Tulip will ultimately depend on your specific needs and goals. Both solutions offer unique features and capabilities and have proven to drive results for their customers. 

By carefully evaluating your needs and goals, you can choose the right smart factory solution for your business and take the first step towards a smarter and more efficient manufacturing operation.

Bryan Sapot
Bryan Sapot
Bryan Sapot is a lifelong entrepreneur, speaker, CEO, and founder of Mingo. With more than 24 years of experience in manufacturing technology, Bryan is known for his deep manufacturing industry insights. Throughout his career, he’s built products and started companies that leveraged technology to solve problems to make the lives of manufacturers easier. Follow Bryan on LinkedIn here.